Kimmie comes to Cage & Fish looking to hire Ally. She's suing her old firm for wrongful termination. They fired her for being too puritan, and the opposite lawyer is Larry. Now Ally and Larry have to face each other in court. Meanwhile, Ally is nervous about her first kiss with Larry and seeks for advice with Ling, who demonstrate on John how a good kiss should go. This makes Richard insecure of himself, and Nelle tells him to find a theme song for himself. John loses the case to Larry, but he and Kimmie go out on a date.
Everybody Loves a Lover — Doris Day
[Live cover version] Opening, Vonda Shepard performs.
Going the Distance — Bill Conti
Cupid / I've Loved You for a Long Time — The Spinners
[Live cover version] Vonda performs, before Ally and Larry's non-kiss.
Isn't It Romantic? — Ella Fitzgerald
Larry kisses Ally on the forehead
I Gotcha — Joe Tex
Fish in the mirror.
Love Machine — The Miracles
Fish in the mirror.
It's Not Unusual — Tom Jones
Fish in the mirror.
Try to Remember — Vonda Shepard
[On-screen performance] Before Ally and Larry's first real kiss
For Once in My Life — Vonda Shepard
[On-screen performance] At the end.