Josh is surprised to find he's living in a romcom; Josh till can't seem to win Arnold over.
I'll Be Fine — Clairy Browne & The Bangin' Rackettes
(Opening credits) Josh & Tom go to the farm to pick up their baby chickens then bring them home; Josh cooks dinner; Arnold arrives, Josh & Tom show him the hens then they all have dinner.
Love Letter — Clairy Browne & The Bangin' Rackettes
Josh, Hannah & Tom discuss Josh & Arnold lack of sex when with all their dinner dates as they shop for furniture when Hannah & Tom begin to make fun of Josh causing him to leave.
Josh sings the words of the song when he realizes that Arnold has planned for them to have sex for the first time on their date; Josh & Arnold have sex for the first time with a bit of a struggle.
(playing on the wireless) Taking notes from the movie "Love, Actually," Arnold apologizes to Josh and tells him he loves him on a montage of poster boards then Josh kiss him in forgiveness.