As the high school prepares to throw a “1960s Decade Dance,” Elena starts receiving disturbing messages from Klaus via an unusual source. Bonnie tries to reassure Jeremy that she is strong enough to help Elena, but a worried Jeremy asks Stefan for advice. Caroline talks Matt into taking her to the dance. Expecting Klaus to show up at the dance, Damon and Alaric attend as chaperones, but Klaus is playing a complicated game that keeps them on edge. Finally, Damon comes up with a new plan of action that shocks and upsets everyone.
Spotlight (Oh Nostalgia) — Patrick Stump
(0:09) Matt and Caroline kiss; Jeremy asks Elena about telling Bonnie to not use her power.
Hush — Kula Shaker
(0:16) Alaric/Klaus looks around the dance and chats with students.
Dedicated to the One I Love — The Mamas & The Papas
Klaus dedicates a song to Elena.
Last Kiss — Trent Dabbs
(0:19) Damon asks Bonnie about the Klaus spell being deadly to her.
I Think We're Alone Now — The Birthday Massacre
(0:24) Elena tells Bonnie that she can't sacrifice her life for her. Damon dances with students.
I Wanna Be (Your Everything) — The Manhattans
(0:25) A group attacks Jeremy in the hallway.
Dream Lover — The Dollyrots
(0:29) Elena runs into Caroline and Matt while looking for Stefan.
That Man (Album Edit) — Caro Emerald
"1960 Decade dance", Caroline talks to Matt about Elena